Crumbl has changed the way people think about cookies. Instead of offering the same menu every day, Crumbl releases new flavors every week. This rotating menu keeps customers excited, always waiting to see what surprise flavor comes next. With hundreds of cookies created over the years, a few flavors stand out as true legends.
In this article, we’ll explore the Top 10 Crumbl Cookie Flavors of all time. These picks are based on fan reviews, social media buzz, repeat appearances on the menu, and overall popularity.
How These Top Flavors Were Chosen
These cookies earned their spot because they:
- Return often due to high demand
- Receive strong ratings from customers
- Sell out quickly in many locations
- Have unique taste and texture
Now, let’s count down the best Crumbl cookies ever made.
1. Chocolate Chip Cookie
The Iconic Classic
The Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie is Crumbl’s signature flavor. It’s soft in the middle, slightly crispy on the edges, and loaded with milk chocolate chips. Served warm, it melts in your mouth.
Why People Love It:
- Always available
- Perfect balance of sweet and buttery
- Comfort food at its best
2. Pink Sugar Cookie
Sweet, Soft, and Famous
This cookie became viral thanks to its pastel pink almond frosting. It has a sugar cookie base with a smooth, sweet icing on top.
Why It’s Special:
- Almond-flavored frosting
- Soft bakery-style texture
- Easily recognizable look
3. Cookies & Cream
Oreo Lovers’ Favorite
This cookie is packed with crushed chocolate cookies inside and topped with creamy frosting and cookie crumbs.
Flavor Highlights:
- Rich chocolate base
- Creamy vanilla topping
- Crunchy cookie bits
4. Brownie Batter Cookie
For Serious Chocolate Fans
Thick, rich, and fudgy, this cookie tastes like underbaked brownie batter.
Why It Ranks High:
- Deep chocolate flavor
- Soft and gooey center
- Perfect with cold milk
5. Snickerdoodle
Cinnamon Comfort
This classic cinnamon sugar cookie is soft, warm, and comforting.
Why People Order It:
- Light cinnamon flavor
- Not overly sweet
- Great for all ages
6. Churro Cookie
Dessert in Cookie Form
Inspired by churros, this cookie is rolled in cinnamon sugar and topped with cinnamon buttercream frosting.
Why It’s a Favorite:
- Sweet cinnamon taste
- Creamy frosting
- Looks beautiful and tastes even better
7. Peanut Butter Blossom
Peanut Butter + Chocolate
A soft peanut butter cookie topped with a chocolate candy in the center.
Why Fans Love It:
- Rich peanut butter base
- Chocolate center
- Nostalgic holiday flavor
8. Lemon Cream Pie Cookie
Fresh and Bright
This cookie has a buttery base with lemon cream topping and crumb garnish.
Why It Stands Out:
- Light, refreshing taste
- Not too heavy
- Perfect after big meals
9. Strawberry Shortcake Cookie
Fruity and Creamy
A vanilla cookie layered with strawberry topping and whipped cream-style frosting.
What Makes It Special:
- Real fruit flavor
- Soft cake-like texture
- Beautiful presentation
10. Cinnamon Roll Cookie
Breakfast-Inspired Dessert
This cookie tastes like a cinnamon roll in cookie form, with cinnamon filling and cream cheese frosting.
Why It’s Popular:
- Rich cinnamon swirl
- Creamy topping
- Great with coffee
Quick Comparison Table
| Rank | Flavor | Main Taste |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Chocolate Chip | Buttery & chocolate |
| 2 | Pink Sugar | Sweet almond |
| 3 | Cookies & Cream | Chocolate & vanilla |
| 4 | Brownie Batter | Fudgy chocolate |
| 5 | Snickerdoodle | Cinnamon sugar |
| 6 | Churro | Cinnamon cream |
| 7 | Peanut Butter Blossom | Peanut butter & chocolate |
| 8 | Lemon Cream Pie | Tangy & sweet |
| 9 | Strawberry Shortcake | Fruity cream |
| 10 | Cinnamon Roll | Cinnamon & frosting |
Honorable Mentions
These flavors almost made the top 10:
- Key Lime Pie
- Pumpkin Chocolate Chip
- Mint Brownie
- Caramel Apple
- Banana Cream Pie
Why Crumbl Cookies Are So Popular
Crumbl stands out because:
- New menu every week
- Big bakery-style cookies
- Unique dessert flavors
- Strong social media presence
People love posting Crumbl boxes online, which makes flavors go viral quickly.
How to Get Your Favorite Flavor
- Check the Crumbl app every Monday
- Order early in the week
- Follow Crumbl on social media
- Join email or app alerts
Final Thoughts
Crumbl has created hundreds of cookies, but only a few earn legendary status. From the classic Chocolate Chip to the rich Cinnamon Roll and refreshing Lemon Cream Pie, these Top 10 Crumbl Cookie Flavors represent the best of the best.
No matter your taste—chocolate, fruity, nutty, or creamy—Crumbl has a flavor that feels made just for you. Keep watching the weekly menu, because your next favorite cookie might be just one Monday away.